AM-produced mandrels provide new market opportunities

Published
July 10, 2023 - 09:45am
3-D printed sacrificial core for duct

By Oleg Yermanok, Application Engineering Manager, Massivit 3D

Additive manufacturing can disrupt industrial processes and facilitate the achievement of innovative, cost-effective and speedy outcomes when compared with traditional production processes.

Coinciding with the rapid growth in demand for products made from composite materials — which are inherently stronger, lighter, and more environmentally resistant than conventional materials — AM is set to revolutionize composite production in the defense, aerospace, and additional industries. In these sectors, it can (among other things) be used to create mandrels for ducts and vents for air, fluid, and energy management applications.

Mandrels are an essential tool when making hollow composite parts and components. During the manufacturing process, the mandrel is inserted into the end of a tube or pipe and held in place while the object is being formed around it. This ensures that the finished product retains its shape and size.

Encapsulated 3D printed mandrel
Top: 3D-printed sacrificial core for duct. Above:  Encapsulated 3D printed mandrel with skin in the bath.​​​​​

Traditionally, the most common type of mandrel is made from steel, but aluminum and other metals can also be used. Such mandrels, however, can have limited applications and can be expensive. This article will explain to engineers from all relevant industrial sectors just how their manufacturing processes can be simplified and optimized through the use of AM to produce mandrels as sacrificial tools for composite manufacturing.

Composite materials, used extensively across many manufacturing sectors, are materials that are made up of two or more distinct components. These components can be a combination of metals, polymers, ceramics, fibers, and various other substances, depending on the application. Composite materials are used in a variety of industrial applications because they offer a number of benefits over traditional materials such as the fact that they are lightweight allowing for fuel efficiency, and exhibit increased strength, increased stability, increased resistance to wear and tear, and increased resistance to weathering and environmental damage. 

Composite materials are also easier to fabricate and mold into complex shapes than the likes of metal, plastic, and ceramic. By combining different types of materials together, engineers can create materials that meet specific requirements and provide lasting service to many industries. With the growing demand for composite materials, it's clear that these versatile materials will continue to play an important role in industry for years to come.

Conventional vs AM
 

3D Printed Sacrificial Mandrel with Carbon Skin
3D printed sacrificial mandrel with carbon skin.

Traditional mandrel-making methods have existed for centuries and are still in use. There are three main traditional methods of making mandrels: casting, forging, and machining.

Casting is the most common method of making industrial mandrels. In this process, molten metal is poured into a mold that is in the shape of the desired mandrel. The metal cools and hardens, and the mandrel is then removed from the mold. In the forging process, a piece of metal is heated until it is malleable, and then it is shaped into the desired mandrel using hammers and other tools. In the machining process, a piece of metal is cut or milled into the desired shape using lathes, milling machines, or other machine tools.

There are a number of inherent disadvantages of using conventional mandrel production technologies, key among which is that they are often time consuming, labor intensive,  often generate a lot of waste material, and they are limited in the extent of geometric complexity that can be achieved.

AM can be used to create mandrels with complex geometries that would be difficult or impossible to produce using traditional methods. AM offers a more flexible approach that can create mandrels with intricate designs and internal features extremely quickly, without the need for expensive cutting tools. Traditional mandrel production methods also require multiple parts to be produced if there are complex geometries or overhangs etc…, otherwise it would not be possible to remove the mandrel core. Producing multiple parts means extra cost, is time-consuming, and opens up the possibility of errors and reworkings.

The benefits of using AM to make mandrels include lower tooling costs, shorter lead times, and greater flexibility in design. Additively manufactured mandrels can be made quickly and easily from a digital file, making them ideal for short-run or one-off production runs. Additionally, they offer designers greater freedom in terms of shape and geometry compared to traditional techniques.

The Massivit solution
 

Carbon air duct skin produced from 3D printed mandrel
Carbon air duct skin produced from 3D printed mandrel.

Massivit 3D has developed a proprietary printing process for producing strong and durable mandrels. This represents a highly innovative solution for the production of composite parts, offering significant advantages over traditional manufacturing methods and enabling the production of high-quality composite parts with reduced lead times and lower costs. 

One of the key advantages of using AM to make mandrels, as just mentioned, is that it allows for much more complex designs than traditional machining methods. With AM, there are no constraints on the geometric shapes that can be produced, meaning that mandrels can be made with very intricate designs. This opens up a whole new range of possibilities for mandrel designs and means that they can be tailor-made to suit the specific needs of a particular application.

As the demand for composite parts increases, so does the need for more efficient and cost-effective production solutions. Massivit has developed the Massivit 10000 AM system to meet these requirements. The machine uses Cast In Motion (CIM) technology in combination with Massivit 3D’s patented Gel Dispensing Printing (GDP) method. It allows the direct casting of the mold into a 3D-printed sacrificial shell. To achieve this, the Massivit 10000 utilizes a dual-head system, ultra-fast patented technology, and for the mandrels uses water-breakable material that crumbles in water. All these allow manufacturers to produce complex mandrels within a matter of hours instead of weeks. 

Massivit’s water-breakable material is perfectly suited to the production of mandrels. Obviously, one of the most notable features of the material is that it crumbles in water. This allows the mandrel to be easily removed from the final product after production. The material is also lightweight (making it easy to handle and transport during the production process); strong and durable (allowing it to be used for a variety of mandrel applications); environmentally friendly, (minimizing waste when compared to subtractive methods and minimizing the need for extensive material storage); and speedy, with mandrels printing in a matter of hours.

The process
 

Duct mandrel being printed on the Massivit 10000 machine.
Duct mandrel being printed on the Massivit 10000 machine.

To illustrate the disruptive nature of the Massivit 3D approach to mandrel production, this case study looks at the process steps involved in the manufacture of a mandrel for the company Kanfit that serves the defense and aerospace sectors. The commissioned mandrel needed to be printed in Massivit’s water breakable material, and the outer surface of the printed mold needed to be very smooth.

First, a CAD model of the mandrel with dimensions X 381 mm, Y 191 mm, and Z 567 mm was created. To make it optimally aligned to Massivit’s 3D printing technology, the flange area of the model was extended digitally for better layup fabrication, and the wall of the mold was designed with three printing contours with a final width of 5.4mm to withstand the vacuum pressures at the fabrication stage. From the finished CAD file, the G-code of the mandrel was created on the Massivit Smart slicer software. The print was designed to use minimum time and material and took in total only 8 hours. The mandrel was produced using Massivit’s water-breakable DIM WB photopolymer material.

The part was then post-processed. The surface was sandpapered, and one coat of epoxy was applied to make the surface of the mandrel airtight.

For the layup stage, the mandrel was set up on a rotating jig, enabling the application of epoxy and carbon-fiber sheets (6 in total) around the tool. Once coated in carbon fiber, the mold entered the vacuum process, where it remained under vacuum pressure for 3 hours. It was then removed and allowed to rest for 24 hours before the final cure. 

The finished mold was placed in plain water for 24 hours, and all remains of the water-breakable material were removed from the skin. The mandrel was then trimmed, and validated in the quality control department before release.

Using AM to produce the mandrel around which composite parts in such applications are made introduces a simplification and streamlining of the process of composite production when compared to legacy mandrel production.

Mandrels made using AM have the potential to revolutionize the way composite parts and components are made. Mandrels produced using AM offer several advantages over traditionally manufactured mandrels. They are lighter, more precise, and can be easily customized to fit the specific needs of each part. This results in faster production times and a reduction in waste. In addition, mandrels made using AM can be produced from advanced materials such as Massivit’s water-breakable material which simplifies removal. 

This enables the production of composite parts that are of higher quality and more reliable. The future of composite part manufacturing is bright with the advent of additively manufactured mandrels, and this technology and Massivit’s 10000 is poised to revolutionize the industry.

Related Glossary Terms

  • ceramics

    ceramics

    Cutting tool materials based on aluminum oxide and silicon nitride. Ceramic tools can withstand higher cutting speeds than cemented carbide tools when machining hardened steels, cast irons and high-temperature alloys.

  • computer-aided design ( CAD)

    computer-aided design ( CAD)

    Product-design functions performed with the help of computers and special software.

  • gang cutting ( milling)

    gang cutting ( milling)

    Machining with several cutters mounted on a single arbor, generally for simultaneous cutting.

  • jig

    jig

    Tooling usually considered to be a stationary apparatus. A jig assists in the assembly or manufacture of a part or device. It holds the workpiece while guiding the cutting tool with a bushing. A jig used in subassembly or final assembly might provide assembly aids such as alignments and adjustments. See fixture.

  • mandrel

    mandrel

    Workholder for turning that fits inside hollow workpieces. Types available include expanding, pin and threaded.

  • milling

    milling

    Machining operation in which metal or other material is removed by applying power to a rotating cutter. In vertical milling, the cutting tool is mounted vertically on the spindle. In horizontal milling, the cutting tool is mounted horizontally, either directly on the spindle or on an arbor. Horizontal milling is further broken down into conventional milling, where the cutter rotates opposite the direction of feed, or “up” into the workpiece; and climb milling, where the cutter rotates in the direction of feed, or “down” into the workpiece. Milling operations include plane or surface milling, endmilling, facemilling, angle milling, form milling and profiling.

  • quality assurance ( quality control)

    quality assurance ( quality control)

    Terms denoting a formal program for monitoring product quality. The denotations are the same, but QC typically connotes a more traditional postmachining inspection system, while QA implies a more comprehensive approach, with emphasis on “total quality,” broad quality principles, statistical process control and other statistical methods.

INDUSTRY NEWS

06/21/2024
Sandvik Coromant is expanding operations in Oconee County, South Carolina. The $29.4 million investment will improve the company’s Westminster production facility.

06/20/2024
“Why do we do what we do?” asked Alexander Zoller, president of ZOLLER Inc., during his welcome and keynote address on the first day of the two-day ZOLLER Open House & Technology Days, which took…

06/13/2024
Shipments of cutting tools, measured by the Cutting Tool Market Report compiled in a collaboration between AMT – The Association For Manufacturing Technology and the U.S. Cutting Tool Institute (…