Shop tackles tall, large, unique parts

Author Holly B. Martin
Published
July 25,2018 - 09:45am

Need a keyway or internal spline cut into an oversize part? Consider calling Reliable EDM Ltd., which bills itself as the largest EDM shop in North America. Unlike most shops, the Houston company specializes in unconventional EDMing of tall, large and otherwise unique parts.

Reliable is a family-owned business led by founder and President Carl Sommer, along with some of his children and even a grandchild.

“We take pride in helping our customers solve their big-part problems,” said Carl’s son Phil Sommer, vice president of operations. “After 32 years, it still excites us to hear a nervous customer ask about the capabilities of EDMing a large part and hearing them breathe a sigh of relief after hearing a bold ‘no problem’ from us.”



A stepped keyway 4" wide × 25.5" long was cut in this 4,900-lb. part using the Ingersoll Gantry 2000 sinker EDM. The 57-ton machine measures 22'×11' and is 17' high. The machine stretches another 5' underground and is supported by a concrete slab 1½' thick. The tank walls can be raised to allow parts up to 53" tall to be submerged. When filled, the tank holds 62 oil drums containing 55 gal. each. The table capacity for this machine is 66,000 lbs.  All images: Reliable EDM


“There are some jobs EDM just can’t do, but if a customer comes in, we’ll try to figure out a way,” said Carl’s son Steve Sommer, senior vice president. “If it’s physically possible, we’ll design the tooling and electrode holders or fixturing to make it work.”

Reliable’s specialties include wire EDM, which uses spark erosion with a brass wire to cut a wide variety of shapes, and sinker, or ram, EDM, which uses a machined graphite electrode to erode a specific shape from a part. The shop has more than 80 EDMs.

Compared with machining processes like milling, EDM is relatively slow and more difficult to perform. Wires can break and must be rethreaded through the partially finished part. Sinker EDM requires designing and machining the graphite electrode—and milling graphite is a filthy job. The sinker process also calls for the part to be immersed in oil or another dielectric fluid, which can be messy and cumbersome, especially in the case of large parts.

On the other hand, EDM has many advantages:

  •  It can cut virtually any conductive material.
  •  It is extremely accurate.
  •  It does not introduce stress into the material, unlike broaching or shaping.
  •  It can produce tiny features with tight tolerances.
  •  It allows the processing of parts that couldn’t be processed any other way.

“EDM is a spark erosion process, so any material that conducts electricity is eligible, from aluminum and copper all the way up to tungsten carbide,” Phil said.



Reliable was able to cut out test specimens from this 40"-tall blowout preventer
using wire EDM. The company can handle parts weighing up to 10,000 lbs.


“One of the beauties of EDM is that some alloys, like Inconel and Hastelloy, are harder and a lot more difficult to machine, but for EDM, hardness doesn’t make a difference,” Steve said. “Carbide is very dense and slower to EDM, but it is conductive, so we can still do it.”

EDM Parts Designs

Phil noted that EDM is usually the answer for parts that cannot be machined conventionally in a cost-effective manner. “On most of our tall-parts work, EDM is the only option. However, we are now finding that we can compete with conventional machining on certain parts.”

Reliable creates a wide range of long keyways, internal helixes and deep cavities in parts that generally can’t be produced with an endmill or other more conventional cutting tools, according to Steve. “We can also create splines deep inside a long part that go through the entire length.”

One of the most interesting tall parts the shop made was a 48"×4" solid rod through which Reliable wire-
EDMed a cutout of the state of Texas that extends all the way through—an amazing piece that couldn’t be produced any other way.

Reliable takes on any job that other shops can’t machine conventionally or cost-effectively.



A customer needed this 16'-long, 27"-dia. tube cut in half lengthwise.
The tube was too large for the machine, so Reliable modified a standard wire EDM to machine it.


“A lot of times, if there’s a run of 100 parts, a shop might find a way to machine it or make tooling for it,” Steve said. “It might cost $8,000 to make a broach for a keyway in a part that’s 3' long, but if they’re just doing one or two pieces, EDM is going to be more cost-effective.”

The company sometimes does production runs on a detail inside a part in which EDM is the only way to remove the material. Engineers often design parts specifically for that process.

What Is Too Large or Tall?

Reliable buys some of the biggest machines available. “We start with those and then modify them,” Steve said. “Our biggest ram machine, the Ingersoll 2000, has close to 5'×10' of X-Y travel with 4.5' in Z, so we can do a lot of big parts just by having a big machine.”

The company specializes in creating workarounds when machines are not large enough for a part. It has cut a pipe in half that was over 40' long with wire EDM and can wire EDM a part up to 62" tall or thick.

According to Steve, with sinker EDM, Reliable has cut a part over 30' long, but it is not going through all 30'. “We would extend such a long part off the table and then just work on one end of it, either building a tank to hold the oil around it or trying to submerge the area where we’re doing the cutting.”

One of the largest ram projects completed at Reliable was a stepped keyway 4"×25.5" long in a giant part that weighed 4,900 lbs.

“If we can get it off the truck and into our building, we usually can EDM the part,” said Phil, who noted the many instances when the company had to rent heavy-duty forklifts to load and move certain heavy parts.

The company has also been known to move an EDM to accommodate a large or heavy part.

Tolerance Issues

Challenges to EDMing large or tall parts include some loss of accuracy with increased part sizes.

“As a general rule for wire EDM, the taller you get, the more difficult it is to keep the wire in tension,” said Steve, who explained that when cutting a keyway through a 30"-thick part, the keyway will tend to be wider in the middle than at the ends. “So you would either have to skim that out or do secondary cuts to leave material in there,” he added.

Before taking on a job, the experts at Reliable try to determine whether the tolerances specified by the customer are doable.

“Standard print tolerances are usually no problem on large parts,” Phil said. “However, we are usually not held to tenths on large and tall parts.”



A Reliable employee had to crawl into the tube to thread the wire for the EDM tube-cutting operation.


Tolerances also are more difficult to hold when sinker EDMing some large parts—for example, when submerging the part becomes difficult and it must be extended off the end of a machine. The challenge is holding the electrode steady inside a deep or large part to prevent any vibration. “In those cases, you have to pay special attention to designing the fixtures to do the burn,” Steve said.

Another challenge is setting up a large part for EDMing and aligning it, especially for parts held off the table.

For large parts, referencing a zero-zero point and locating the starting position is tricky, according to Steve. “If you have a big, long pipe and you’re trying to get the inside diameter where you can do the cut, you have to put a probe in there and pick up your part, and that becomes a challenge too.”

With its strong emphasis on customer service, some of the largest equipment available and many years of successfully EDMing tall and large parts, Reliable strives to distinguish itself. 

“Our staff of experienced machinists enjoys the challenge of out-of-the-ordinary parts,” Phil said. “This type of work makes our company very interesting.”

For more information about Reliable EDM Ltd., call (800) WIREEDM or visit www.reliableedm.com.   

 

A Talent for Teaching

Reliable EDM’s Carl Sommer began his career in 1949 in a Brooklyn, N.Y., machine shop. His career took a dramatic turn in 1970 when he became a high school teacher in New York City, during which time he wrote a book on practical solutions to problems in education, Schools in Crisis: Training for Success or Failure

Another twist in his career path occurred in 1978 when Carl moved his family to Houston and went to work at a tool and die maker, progressing to the level of manager of operations. Then in 1986, Carl purchased a single wire EDM and struck out on his own with the help of his sons.



Left to right: Steve Sommer, senior vice president; Carl Sommer, president; Phil Sommer,
vice president of operations; and Carl’s grandson, Andrew Sommer, all work at Reliable EDM.


Using his talent for teaching, Carl wrote and distributed pamphlets to educate prospective customers about the benefits of EDMs. Eventually, those pamphlets became a college textbook, The Complete EDM Handbook, written with his son Steve. Carl has also recorded educational videos on all aspects of EDM, which are available on the Reliable EDM website.

But according to Carl, his greatest career achievement has been using his success in business and education to write and publish more than 100 award-winning books teaching character and social skills to children. His latest project, with the help of his son John, is a new phonics-based literacy program that will incorporate the children’s books.

“The real purpose of Reliable EDM is to make money for my publishing company and video studio so that I can help children succeed,” Carl said.

—H. Martin

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Related Glossary Terms

  • alloys

    alloys

    Substances having metallic properties and being composed of two or more chemical elements of which at least one is a metal.

  • broach

    broach

    Tapered tool, with a series of teeth of increasing length, that is pushed or pulled into a workpiece, successively removing small amounts of metal to enlarge a hole, slot or other opening to final size.

  • broaching

    broaching

    Operation in which a cutter progressively enlarges a slot or hole or shapes a workpiece exterior. Low teeth start the cut, intermediate teeth remove the majority of the material and high teeth finish the task. Broaching can be a one-step operation, as opposed to milling and slotting, which require repeated passes. Typically, however, broaching also involves multiple passes.

  • electrical-discharge machining ( EDM)

    electrical-discharge machining ( EDM)

    Process that vaporizes conductive materials by controlled application of pulsed electrical current that flows between a workpiece and electrode (tool) in a dielectric fluid. Permits machining shapes to tight accuracies without the internal stresses conventional machining often generates. Useful in diemaking.

  • endmill

    endmill

    Milling cutter held by its shank that cuts on its periphery and, if so configured, on its free end. Takes a variety of shapes (single- and double-end, roughing, ballnose and cup-end) and sizes (stub, medium, long and extra-long). Also comes with differing numbers of flutes.

  • gang cutting ( milling)

    gang cutting ( milling)

    Machining with several cutters mounted on a single arbor, generally for simultaneous cutting.

  • hardness

    hardness

    Hardness is a measure of the resistance of a material to surface indentation or abrasion. There is no absolute scale for hardness. In order to express hardness quantitatively, each type of test has its own scale, which defines hardness. Indentation hardness obtained through static methods is measured by Brinell, Rockwell, Vickers and Knoop tests. Hardness without indentation is measured by a dynamic method, known as the Scleroscope test.

  • milling

    milling

    Machining operation in which metal or other material is removed by applying power to a rotating cutter. In vertical milling, the cutting tool is mounted vertically on the spindle. In horizontal milling, the cutting tool is mounted horizontally, either directly on the spindle or on an arbor. Horizontal milling is further broken down into conventional milling, where the cutter rotates opposite the direction of feed, or “up” into the workpiece; and climb milling, where the cutter rotates in the direction of feed, or “down” into the workpiece. Milling operations include plane or surface milling, endmilling, facemilling, angle milling, form milling and profiling.

  • ram EDM

    ram EDM

    Process using a shaped electrode made from graphite or copper. The electrode is separated by a nonconductive liquid and maintained at a close distance (about 0.001"). A high DC voltage is pulsed to the electrode and jumps to the conductive workpiece. The resulting sparks erode the workpiece and generate a cavity in the reverse shape of the electrode, or a through-hole in the case of a plain electrode. Permits machining shapes to tight accuracies without the internal stresses conventional machining often generates. Also known as “die-sinker” or “sinker” electrical-discharge machining.

  • relief

    relief

    Space provided behind the cutting edges to prevent rubbing. Sometimes called primary relief. Secondary relief provides additional space behind primary relief. Relief on end teeth is axial relief; relief on side teeth is peripheral relief.

  • shaping

    shaping

    Using a shaper primarily to produce flat surfaces in horizontal, vertical or angular planes. It can also include the machining of curved surfaces, helixes, serrations and special work involving odd and irregular shapes. Often used for prototype or short-run manufacturing to eliminate the need for expensive special tooling or processes.

  • tolerance

    tolerance

    Minimum and maximum amount a workpiece dimension is allowed to vary from a set standard and still be acceptable.

  • tungsten carbide ( WC)

    tungsten carbide ( WC)

    Intermetallic compound consisting of equal parts, by atomic weight, of tungsten and carbon. Sometimes tungsten carbide is used in reference to the cemented tungsten carbide material with cobalt added and/or with titanium carbide or tantalum carbide added. Thus, the tungsten carbide may be used to refer to pure tungsten carbide as well as co-bonded tungsten carbide, which may or may not contain added titanium carbide and/or tantalum carbide.

  • wire EDM

    wire EDM

    Process similar to ram electrical-discharge machining except a small-diameter copper or brass wire is used as a traveling electrode. Usually used in conjunction with a CNC and only works when a part is to be cut completely through. A common analogy is wire electrical-discharge machining is like an ultraprecise, electrical, contour-sawing operation.