Countersinking Aircraft Materials

Author William Cleveland
Published
October 01,1997 - 12:00pm
The aircraft industry’s increased use of titanium and abrasive composites has led to the development of a new generation of countersinks.

Aircraft manufacturers’ primary skill is the ability to fasten two pieces of material together in such a way that they don’t fly apart at Mach 3 in a 90° turn. This requires precision hole preparation prior to the insertion of the fastener - specifically, countersinking.

In the late 1930s, the microstop cage unit was developed. A threaded-shank countersink is screwed into the unit, which is driven by a hand-held drill motor and allows the mechanic to adjust the depth of the countersink in 0.001" increments with good accuracy and repeatability. The basic design of the microstop units has not changed much in the last 60 years. Today’s microstop units are, however, much sturdier and more accurate, incorporating improved bearing technology to achieve the higher rpm rates required for today’s exotic materials (Figure 1).

Aircraft manufacturers are interested in improved versions of these manually operated tools, despite the automation of their processes. Automated fastening is increasing in use as machines are developed with the capability of processing larger panels. For example, a wing may be assembled on a very large Gem-Cor machine, a large jig upon which the wing is set. A preprogrammed robot drills and countersinks the hole in one operation using a combination drill/countersink (the robot also inserts the fastener and shaves the fastener head if required).

However, the vast majority of hole countersinking is still done in a separate operation utilizing hand-held microstop cage units, because building a machine big enough to handle large airplane parts is impractical in most cases.

 

Figure 1: A microstop cage unit used for hand-held countersinking operations.

New Materials, New Tools

In the past, airplanes were constructed primarily of aluminum. HSS countersinks of a 2- or 3-flute configuration were the industry standard. With the advent of titanium and other tough and abrasive materials, 2- and 3-flute carbide tools began to make inroads into the industry. The composite materials of today are even more abrasive and require the use of polycrystalline-diamond (PCD) cutting edges.

Threaded countersinks come with either removable or integral pilots. The integral-pilot style (Figure 2) predominates, because it has a controlled fillet radius at the intersection of the angle and the pilot, which is generally favored by the aircraft industry for countersinking. This design eliminates the sharp corner, which is a stress point on the tool. The radius is ground at the same time the pilot is ground to ensure tangency.

In most cases, if such a radius were ground into a removable-pilot tool, the user could employ only one size of pilot for that tool. This eliminates the chief advantage of a removable-pilot tool - to allow the use of many different pilots so that a separate countersink isn’t needed for each hole size. And if the pilot did not line up correctly because of runout in the hole or pilot shank, the user might score the hole or end up with a partial radius in the workpiece.

 

Figure 2: An integral-pilot carbide countersink.

The carbide version of the integral-pilot tool is manufactured in two ways: carbide tipped, in which the cutting edges are carbide and the pilot is HSS; or solid carbide, in which the entire front end of the tool is carbide. The carbide-tipped tool is less expensive but has a shorter tool life than the solid tool, due to the wear on the HSS pilot. The more abrasive the workpiece material is, the shorter the tool life. The solid-carbide tool is superior if one considers cost per hole rather than cost per tool.

Coping With Composites

The increased use of composite materials in the aircraft industry has changed the type and configuration of countersinks used today. The primary change has been higher degrees of clearance - 16° to 20° primary on a PCD tool as compared to 6° to 10° on a carbide tool for titanium or 3° to 4° on an HSS tool for steel. Tools designed to cut Kevlar® additionally have a sweeping hooked flute combined with a high clearance angle.

For composites, PCD is the optimal tool material. In composite-material applications, HSS usually doesn’t work at all due to highly accelerated tool wear. Carbide will work, but with greatly reduced tool life compared to its performance in titanium. Nevertheless, it is sometimes necessary to use carbide rather than PCD when a certain geometry required on the cutting tool cannot be achieved with PCD blanks - for example, a drillpoint or a radically hooked face for a more burr-free countersink in Kevlar. See Table 1 for recommended cutting tool materials for various workpiece materials.

PCD cannot be used in ferrous materials. Because it is carbon-based, under heat it will become one with the workpiece. Thus it is limited to nonferrous and composite applications. Ferrous machining requires carbide or HSS tools.

 

WORKPIECE MATERIAL CUTTING TOOL MATERIAL
  Good Better Best
Graphite Epoxy

--

Carbide

PCD

Titanium

--

--

Carbide

Aluminum

HSS

Carbide

PCD

Fiberglass

--

Carbide

PCD

Plastic

HSS

Carbide

PCD

Mild Steel

--

HSS

Carbide

Table 1: Tool-material recommendations for various aircraft materials.

Coolant should not be applied when countersinking composites using PCD tools. Coolant has a tendency to react with the composite and cause delamination. And it isn’t really necessary, because PCD has very good heat-transfer characteristics. When using carbide on composites, a cold-air spray may help.

 

Figure 3: A radiused PCD countersink with replaceable blades and pilots.

PCD Shapes Up

One of the problems shops face when working with PCD is the limited ability to grind certain tool geometries. But Craig Tools Inc., El Segundo, CA, has developed a tool that addresses this problem—the Versi-Sink, a replaceable-blade, removable-pilot, threaded-shank countersink (Figure 3). Unlike other PCD countersinks, the replaceable-blade tool has a controlled fillet radius. Normally, this filleted radius is difficult to achieve on a PCD countersink, especially in a 2-flute configuration, without causing lip-height variation. Craig accomplished this by grinding the blades separately on a specially jigged machine and then mechanically holding the blades in the body. The Versi-Sink accepts replaceable blades that have the controlled radius or replaceable straight blades for use when the radius is not required. The tool can be used in a 1- or 2-flute configuration. The pilot also is replaceable, so that as it wears out or the hole size to be machined changes, a new pilot can be installed and the same set of blades used. The radius will remain tangent to the pilot diameter as the insert locates on a ground flat on the pilot shank and can be set by the mechanic without the use of an optical comparator. This provides more versatility than the traditional removable-pilot countersink.

A brazed-tip, 2-flute, nonradiused PCD countersink can be used when the fillet radius is not required (Figure 4). The 2-flute design is generally preferable to 1- or 3-flute designs. Balance and cutting action is superior as long as the tool has good lip height. If one flute protrudes too much, then chatter and egg-shaped holes will result. In the past, this problem was more prevalent, so users opted for 1-flute PCD countersinks to avoid this problem and to minimize the diamond cost.

 

Figure 4: A nonradiused PCD countersink with replaceable blades and pilots.

The 2-flute brazed PCD countersink is easy to recondition, provided the user has the right equipment. These tools, like all PCD tools, have very high clearance angles that must be maintained when the tool is reground to prevent a drastic reduction in performance. This problem often occurs when a user attempts to service these tools in-house. PCD is extremely difficult to grind on a standard tool-and-cutter grinder. In attempting to just clean up the cutting edge, the operator may reduce the amount of clearance by removing less material to make the job easier. This practice effectively reduces the clearance at the cutting edge. Therefore, it is usually much more cost-effective to send the tool back to the manufacturer for reconditioning.

Cost Per Hole

The following is a cost-per-hole comparison of a graphite-epoxy-laminate application:

 

HSS cutter 30 to 50 holes
Carbide-tipped cutter 300 to 500 holes
PCD-tipped cutter with fillet radius 5000 to 10,000 holes
HSS cutter @ $5 each, no resharpening $5/50 holes=$0.10/hole
Carbide cutter @ $28 each, two resharpenings @ $8.35 each ot $16.70 reconditioning cost $44.70/1500 holes=$0.03/hole
PCD-insert cutter with fillet radius @ $39.45 each, 10 pilots @ $19.85 each or $198.50, insert set @ $220.75 each, three resharpenings @ $83.75 or $251.25 reconditioning cost. $709.95/40,000 holes = $0.0177/hole

The HSS, integral-pilot, threaded-shank countersink probably will never be phased out completely, but there is a definite trend toward more carbide and PCD tools. The sticker shock of PCD is slowly fading as the cost-per-hole savings becomes more widely recognized. Many companies have seen their perishable-tooling costs increase dramatically as they purchase more and more carbide tools to meet the demands of their shops and get fewer and fewer holes per tool due to increased composite-material applications. The PCD tool then becomes much more attractive as a means to reducing costs and increasing productivity through greatly reduced tool changes and a radically higher number of holes per tool.

The cutting tool industry can look forward to increased use of composites in all areas of manufacturing. In the aircraft industry, this means a continuing shift toward carbide, PCD, and coated tools. Cost per hole will always be the deciding factor in cutting tool selection.

About the Author

William Cleveland is president of Craig Tools Inc., El Segundo, CA. He also serves as president of the United States Cutting Tool Institute, Cleveland.

Related Glossary Terms

  • abrasive

    abrasive

    Substance used for grinding, honing, lapping, superfinishing and polishing. Examples include garnet, emery, corundum, silicon carbide, cubic boron nitride and diamond in various grit sizes.

  • chatter

    chatter

    Condition of vibration involving the machine, workpiece and cutting tool. Once this condition arises, it is often self-sustaining until the problem is corrected. Chatter can be identified when lines or grooves appear at regular intervals in the workpiece. These lines or grooves are caused by the teeth of the cutter as they vibrate in and out of the workpiece and their spacing depends on the frequency of vibration.

  • clearance

    clearance

    Space provided behind a tool’s land or relief to prevent rubbing and subsequent premature deterioration of the tool. See land; relief.

  • coated tools

    coated tools

    Carbide and high-speed-steel tools coated with thin layers of aluminum oxide, titanium carbide, titanium nitride, hafnium nitride or other compounds. Coating improves a tool’s resistance to wear, allows higher machining speeds and imparts better finishes. See CVD, chemical vapor deposition; PVD, physical vapor deposition.

  • composites

    composites

    Materials composed of different elements, with one element normally embedded in another, held together by a compatible binder.

  • coolant

    coolant

    Fluid that reduces temperature buildup at the tool/workpiece interface during machining. Normally takes the form of a liquid such as soluble or chemical mixtures (semisynthetic, synthetic) but can be pressurized air or other gas. Because of water’s ability to absorb great quantities of heat, it is widely used as a coolant and vehicle for various cutting compounds, with the water-to-compound ratio varying with the machining task. See cutting fluid; semisynthetic cutting fluid; soluble-oil cutting fluid; synthetic cutting fluid.

  • countersink

    countersink

    Tool that cuts a sloped depression at the top of a hole to permit a screw head or other object to rest flush with the surface of the workpiece.

  • countersinking

    countersinking

    Cutting a beveled edge at the entrance of a hole so a screw head sits flush with the workpiece surface.

  • cutting tool materials

    cutting tool materials

    Cutting tool materials include cemented carbides, ceramics, cermets, polycrystalline diamond, polycrystalline cubic boron nitride, some grades of tool steels and high-speed steels. See HSS, high-speed steels; PCBN, polycrystalline cubic boron nitride; PCD, polycrystalline diamond.

  • fillet

    fillet

    Rounded corner or arc that blends together two intersecting curves or lines. In three dimensions, a fillet surface is a transition surface that blends together two surfaces.

  • flat ( screw flat)

    flat ( screw flat)

    Flat surface machined into the shank of a cutting tool for enhanced holding of the tool.

  • grinding

    grinding

    Machining operation in which material is removed from the workpiece by a powered abrasive wheel, stone, belt, paste, sheet, compound, slurry, etc. Takes various forms: surface grinding (creates flat and/or squared surfaces); cylindrical grinding (for external cylindrical and tapered shapes, fillets, undercuts, etc.); centerless grinding; chamfering; thread and form grinding; tool and cutter grinding; offhand grinding; lapping and polishing (grinding with extremely fine grits to create ultrasmooth surfaces); honing; and disc grinding.

  • high-speed steels ( HSS)

    high-speed steels ( HSS)

    Available in two major types: tungsten high-speed steels (designated by letter T having tungsten as the principal alloying element) and molybdenum high-speed steels (designated by letter M having molybdenum as the principal alloying element). The type T high-speed steels containing cobalt have higher wear resistance and greater red (hot) hardness, withstanding cutting temperature up to 1,100º F (590º C). The type T steels are used to fabricate metalcutting tools (milling cutters, drills, reamers and taps), woodworking tools, various types of punches and dies, ball and roller bearings. The type M steels are used for cutting tools and various types of dies.

  • jig

    jig

    Tooling usually considered to be a stationary apparatus. A jig assists in the assembly or manufacture of a part or device. It holds the workpiece while guiding the cutting tool with a bushing. A jig used in subassembly or final assembly might provide assembly aids such as alignments and adjustments. See fixture.

  • metalcutting ( material cutting)

    metalcutting ( material cutting)

    Any machining process used to part metal or other material or give a workpiece a new configuration. Conventionally applies to machining operations in which a cutting tool mechanically removes material in the form of chips; applies to any process in which metal or material is removed to create new shapes. See metalforming.

  • polycrystalline diamond ( PCD)

    polycrystalline diamond ( PCD)

    Cutting tool material consisting of natural or synthetic diamond crystals bonded together under high pressure at elevated temperatures. PCD is available as a tip brazed to a carbide insert carrier. Used for machining nonferrous alloys and nonmetallic materials at high cutting speeds.

  • shank

    shank

    Main body of a tool; the portion of a drill or similar end-held tool that fits into a collet, chuck or similar mounting device.

Author

President

William Cleveland is president of Craig Tools Inc., El Segundo, California.