March 2012 / Volume 64 / Issue 3|
Machine bed support key to accuracy
By Dr. Scott Smith, University of North Carolina at Charlotte
All images Courtesy of S. Smith
A machine tool bed serves several important functions. It supports the machine’s moving elements and supports them in geometric relation to each other. The relationship between the moving elements is more important than the relationship between the moving elements and the ground the machine is based on.
It is typically desirable for the bed to be as flat as possible, which requires considerable effort to scrape or grind the surfaces on which the guide ways are mounted. The bed should be stiff, thermally stable and able to absorb or dissipate vibration. When the machine is installed, the bed must be aligned.
Bed flatness depends on the connection between the bed and the foundation. In geometry, three noncollinear points are enough to define a plane. If the machine bed is very stiff, then three connection points between the bed and the foundation are sufficient to support the bed. In such a case, machine accuracy does not depend on foundation accuracy. Machines with work spaces up to a cubic meter or more can be found with three mounting points.
Even a stiff bed is not infinitely stiff. The bed sags a little between the mounting points. The sag can be minimized by placing the supports, or feet, at the Airy points (Figure 1). (Airy points are used in precision measurement to support a length standard in such a way as to minimize bending or drooping.) The distance between the supports (d) should be about 60 percent of the bed length (L).
The distance from either end of the bed to the supports should, therefore, be about 20 percent of the bed length. In Figure 1, two of the three supports should be aligned on Airy points, and the third support should be centered on the bed (see Figure 2 on page 24). With three-point mounting, machine alignment is maintained, even if the temperature changes and the bed has a different coefficient of thermal expansion than the floor.
As a machine gets larger, it becomes unfeasible to support the machine on three points, and more feet are required. A large machine may have 20 or more feet. When the machine is installed, screws adjust the portion of the machine weight carried by each foot, and bed flatness and straightness is repeatedly measured.
With larger machines, the bed derives some of its stiffness from the foundation, which is typically comprised of thick slabs of reinforced concrete. The larger the machine, the thicker and stiffer the slabs should be. In some cases, mounting bolts embedded in the foundation are used to pull the bed toward the floor.
Unfortunately, for machines with more than three mounting points, the geometric accuracy of the machine changes as the foundation changes. Curing and settling of the concrete can change machine alignment over a period of months or years. Temperature changes on a 1-day time scale also cause the machine to move with respect to the foundation, reducing machine accuracy.
At this scale, calculations of bed and foundation deflection in response to machine load begin to resemble those used for foundations of buildings, roads and railroads. Classic equations developed in 1926 by H.M. Westergaard for calculations like these consider the size and weight of the loads, geometry of the mounting pads, concrete thickness, reinforcement, modulus of elasticity and reaction of the subgrade.
For extremely large machines, even the curvature of the Earth can be a substantial fraction of the tolerance. A machine with a travel of 40m might have a straightness tolerance of 160µm, and the Earth’s curvature over this distance is 32µm. (See “Measurement techniques for determining the static stiffness of foundations for machine tools,” A. Myers, S.M. Barrans and D.G. Ford, Journal of Physics: Con- ference Series 13, 2005, pgs. 410 to 413.) CTEAbout the Author: Dr. Scott Smith is a professor and chair of the Department of Mechanical Engineering at the William States Lee College of Engineering, University of North Carolina at Charlotte. Contact him via e-mail at firstname.lastname@example.org.
CUTTING TOOL ENGINEERING Magazine is protected under U.S. and international copyright laws. Before reproducing anything from this Web site, call the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. |
at (978) 750-8400.